A Closer Look at Carl's Letter to Negan on The Walking Dead
Series creator Robert Kirkman offers some explanation on why Carl felt the need to leave a message for Negan.
By Chris Morse
The final moments of Carl Grimes were punctuated by his belief that there is still a chance for peace, even in the very end. When The Walking Dead returned from its midseason hiatus, we learned that the bitten son of Rick made the most of his time, and spent a little time writing letters with a final message for each of the other characters he was closest to. Among those letters was one addressed to Negan himself, whose Saviors are currently at war with our survivors.
So what exactly did our younger hero have to say and why? The creator of The Walking Dead, Robert Kirkman, had a bit to say on this on the zombie drama's after-show, The Talking Dead. "I think Negan and Carl have this really unique relationship," he said. "It's a little more developed in the comics but it's definitely present in the television show. When you look at those thoughts that Carl is having in the future, Negan is very much a part of that. He sees the good in Negan, even if no one else does."
The previous episode ended with a heated conversation between a not-so-calm-and-collected Rick, and Negan, who expressed genuine sympathy and disappointment after learning of the grim news. In this moment, Rick is still processing the loss and isn't really living up to his promise to his late son in finding a better way to do this. The confrontation leads Negan to blame Rick for the death of Carl. On whether he really means that, here's what Kirkman had to say:
He definitely does. He is of the mindset that his way of life is the best way to go about things. Rick is screwing that up and in screwing that up, he got his son killed. I think Negan truly believes that if Rick had submitted and gone with the Saviors, Carl would still be alive.
So what exactly did Carl's letter say to Negan that set Rick off so much? A user on Reddit posted up the following enlarged picture for other fans to look closer and share whatever they could make out. Here's the quick shot we saw of the letter:
Another user, awakeningosiris, offered up a pretty good transcript of what could be made out. Parts of the letter are covered up in the shot, but we can make out a few sentences and get a decent picture of what Carl had to say to the enemy on the other side of this war:
“Negan. This is Carl......someone. I got bit. We didn’t even have......doing... I was just helping someone. And now.....
You might be gone. Maybe my dad killed you - but I don’t think so. I think you(re?) working on a way out. Maybe you got out. Maybe...... lost cause and you just want to kill all of us. I think you have to be who you are. I ju.....s what you wanted. I wanted to ask you....I.....aybe you’ll beat us. If you do, there’ll just (be someone?)..... the way out is working together. It’s forgiving....”
And then I can see “offers you peace” and “start” near the bottom
We can see the general sentiment of coming together in peace in this message, just as the late son of Rick Grimes expressed shortly before his death. While it seems unlikely both sides are about to give up, this is an important point that might guide a few critical moments before the season is over. We have about 6 more weeks to find out where we're heading. As for us here at Dead Entertainment, we're still hoping we'll get a tease at the future before the season is over.
Weekly Horror News Round-Up October 17: Friday the 13th, The Walking Dead, Day of the Dead
Plus, I Know What You Did Last Summer gets the green light, You adds to its Season 3 cast, and more.
Weekly Horror News Round-Up October 24: Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Creepshow, Candyman
Plus, Tim Burton sets his sights on The Addams Family, Kane Hodder investigates the paranormal, Ghostbusters moves to summer, and more.
Weekly Horror News Round-Up October 10: The Stand, Resident Evil, The Witcher
Plus, an early teaser drops for The Addams Family 2, The Walking Dead meets Magic: The Gathering, Netflix announces a Godzilla anime, and more.
Weekly Horror News Round-Up October 3: Resident Evil, The Craft: Legacy, The Haunting of Bly Manor
Plus, Stranger Things 4 resumes production, Michael Dougherty signs on to direct the Nightbreed TV adaptation, Terrifier 2 gets delayed, and more.